What we found
- No single winner. The two most named firms appeared in 29.5% and 27.7% of answers. At least ten different firms led at least one question.
- Practice areas have owners. One firm was named in 93% of answers about wrongful death lawyers; another in 90% about medical malpractice. Specialists win the specific questions.
- Fee questions are wide open. On "How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Chicago?", no firm was named in more than 10% of answers. Most cost and comparison questions sat under 20%.
- Legal directories carry the most weight. Super Lawyers profiles were cited in 182 answers, Avvo in 147, Expertise in 118, Justia in 117, FindLaw in 79 and Best Law Firms in 77.
- ChatGPT reads the court record. It cited Illinois court documents in 59 of its 210 answers, and in 28 of 36 answers about fees.
- Google's AI reads Google. Google's own business listings appeared in 82% of AI Overview answers and 51% of AI Mode answers.
- Each engine has its own favourite. The firm Gemini named most (49% of its answers) was not the one ChatGPT named most (28%), and Google's AI Overview had a third leader (40%).
Chicago is one market. What about yours?
Most firms have never seen what ChatGPT says when someone asks for a lawyer in their city after an accident. Find out if you are on the short list, and which sites the answer trusted instead of you.
A crowded top of the list
Twelve firms were named in 8% or more of all 1,021 answers. Compare that with our Houston roofing study, where one roofer took 34% and the next under 15%. In personal injury law the top is crowded, so small changes in what the engines read move firms up and down. We do not publish the names.
Every engine reads a different web
The engines cited 659 websites. 480 of them (73%) were cited by one engine only, and just 14 by all five. That is why the leader changes from engine to engine.
| Engine | Sources per answer | Sites it cited most | Its most named firm |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 19.4 | Avvo (40% of answers), law firm sites, BBB, Expertise, Illinois court records | Firm A, 28% |
| Gemini | 2.4 | Super Lawyers profiles, law firm sites, Attorney at Law Magazine | Firm B, 49% |
| Perplexity | 10.0 | OnToplist (34%), Super Lawyers (31%), Expertise, Avvo, Justia | Firm B, 37% |
| Google AI Mode | 3.9 | Google business listings (51%), law firm sites, Super Lawyers, Thumbtack | Firm A, 39% |
| Google AI Overview | 6.0 | Google business listings (82%), YouTube (15%), law firm sites | Firm C, 40% |
For a law firm this means two different jobs. Google's two AI features run on your Google Business Profile and its reviews. ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini run on legal directories, rating sites and your own pages.
The sites that feed the answers
The number of the 1,021 answers that cited each site at least once.
| Site | Answers citing it | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Google (business listings and Maps) | 266 | 26.1% |
| Super Lawyers | 182 | 17.8% |
| Avvo | 147 | 14.4% |
| Expertise.com | 118 | 11.6% |
| Justia | 117 | 11.5% |
| FindLaw | 79 | 7.7% |
| Best Law Firms | 77 | 7.5% |
| BBB | 58 | 5.7% |
| YouTube | 35 | 3.4% |
| Martindale | 23 | 2.3% |
| Yelp | 20 | 2.0% |
Law firm websites were cited heavily too: one firm's site appeared in 147 answers. The engines cite the firm pages that state results, practice areas and fees plainly.
Where firms win and where nobody does
The 35 questions covered "who is best" questions, specific case types, fees and comparisons. The share below is how often the most named firm for that question appeared.
| Question | Top firm named in |
|---|---|
| Who are the best wrongful death lawyers in Chicago? | 93% |
| Who is the best medical malpractice lawyer in Chicago? | 90% |
| Who is the best personal injury lawyer in Chicago? | 77% |
| Who are the best truck accident lawyers in Chicago? | 74% |
| Who is the best car accident lawyer in Chicago? | 70% |
| Which Chicago injury lawyers offer a free consultation? | 47% |
| How much does a dog bite lawyer cost in Chicago? | 30% |
| How much do personal injury lawyers in Chicago charge? | 17% |
| What do wrongful death lawyers in Chicago charge as a contingency fee? | 13% |
| How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Chicago? | 10% |
| Is a big Chicago personal injury firm better than a small one? | 7% |
| What should I look for when choosing a personal injury lawyer in Chicago? | 3% |
What this means for your law firm SEO
AI visibility does not replace law firm SEO; it rewards the same groundwork, spread across more places. In order of impact in this data:
- Complete your Google Business Profile. Google's AI Overview cited Google's listings in 82% of its answers. Categories for each practice area, hours, photos, and a steady flow of reviews.
- Own your legal directory profiles. Super Lawyers, Avvo, Justia, FindLaw, Expertise and Best Law Firms together appear in most non-Google answers. Same firm name, address, practice areas and attorneys on each.
- Give every practice area its own page. Specialists won the specific questions by wide margins. A wrongful death page, a truck accident page and a medical malpractice page, each with your results and attorneys, give the engines something to quote.
- Publish your fees and the "how to choose" answer. These questions had no owner. Explain contingency fees in your state, typical percentages, costs and what a free consultation covers, in plain words and with a date.
- List your awards, certifications and case results on your site. The engines cite firm pages directly. If your recognitions are only on a plaque in the office, the AI cannot see them.
- Measure each engine separately. A different firm led on each engine. Check all five, and re-check after each change, because answers vary from one ask to the next.
Step 6, measured for you
GEO Engine, our AI visibility tool, runs this kind of measurement for your firm, in your city:
- About 40 questions clients ask, on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews, each asked three times
- The firms the AI names instead of you, by practice area and by engine
- The directories and pages each engine relies on in your market, and wrong facts it repeats about you
- A step-by-step action plan with ready drafts, and weekly tracking between full measurements

Monthly, cancel any time, 30-day money-back guarantee.
How we measured
On November 20, 2026 we asked 35 questions a person in Chicago might ask after an injury: "who is best" questions for each case type (car, truck and motorcycle accidents, medical malpractice, wrongful death, dog bites, slip and fall), fee questions, comparisons (big firm or small, local or national) and trust questions. Each question was asked six times on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode, and six times on Google search to capture an AI Overview when one appeared (it did in 181 of 210 searches). That gave 1,021 answers and 8,574 citations. A firm counts as named when the answer recommends it by name. Shares are rounded; results describe one city on one date, and AI answers change over time. This is research, not legal advice, and it says nothing about the quality of any firm's work.
Questions law firms ask
How do I get my law firm recommended by ChatGPT?
Be present and consistent on the sites ChatGPT reads for your city. In Chicago those were Avvo, Super Lawyers, Expertise, Justia, BBB and the firms' own sites, plus court records. Give each practice area its own page with results and attorneys, publish clear fee information, and keep your firm's details identical everywhere.
Does traditional SEO still matter for law firms?
Yes. Google's AI Overview cited Google's own business listings in 82% of its answers and AI Mode in 51%, and every engine leaned on pages that already rank. AI visibility is built on a strong Google Business Profile and a site that ranks, not instead of them.
Which legal directories matter most for AI?
In our Chicago data: Super Lawyers (cited in 182 answers), Avvo (147), Expertise (118), Justia (117), FindLaw (79) and Best Law Firms (77). Each engine has its favourites: ChatGPT leaned on Avvo, Perplexity on OnToplist and Super Lawyers, Gemini on Super Lawyers.
Is personal injury law different from other practice areas?
The pattern of one owner per specific case type and open fee questions is likely to hold in other practice areas, but the directories differ. Family, criminal and estate lawyers should measure their own market rather than assume.
How do I see where my firm stands?
Run the free AI visibility check. It asks two client questions on ChatGPT and Google's AI Mode and shows whether you are named and which sites the answers relied on. To track all five engines over time, see the GEO Engine plans.
See where your firm stands
Ask the AI what your clients ask. In about a minute you see whether ChatGPT and Google's AI Mode name you, who they name instead, and the sites they trusted.
Ready for the full picture? GEO Engine plans start at $79/month, with a 30-day money-back guarantee.